In response to my previous posting, a friend remarked " but, Indians are xenophobic". Upon questioning him on the basis for his rather sweeping statement, he said it was based on a report that he had read in some newspaper, where some Chinese immigrants in India claimed that they were discriminated against by the local populace. Possible, but on the basis of the evidence presented can hardly warrant a statement that indicts a billion people.
Anyway, my initial reaction was, this is BS. But, on giving it more thought I did think it was possible. Of course, I would not go so far as to call them Xenophobic, but most definitely I can understand Indians being wary and skeptical of foreigners and outsiders. Let me try and elaborate why I would think as such. For this purpose, I am merely going to depend on my memory to help me with some details; if there are any factual inaccuracies they would be my own doing, so please provide your corrections, if any, using the comment section below.
India, like China is a "civilization-state". One of the world's oldest civilization, that in the 20th century went on to become a nation state after winning its independence from the British in 1947. It has a rich history from which one can draw some insights into the behaviour of its people.
The earliest documented interactions of the Indic people with "foreigners" was during the times of the Chandragupta Mauraya. Megasthenes, a Greek traveller and scholar spent some a few years in Chandragupta's court. It is from his book "Indica" that we learn a lot about that period ( For all the trivia buffs out there- the Tata car "Indica" derives it's name from this very book.). This book documents the cultural exchanges and also the trade between the Indians and Greeks. Needless to say there seemed to be no signs of xenophobia then.
Moving ahead, during the reign of Harsha Vardhana, several Chinese travellers visited and lived in present day India. Most notable among them were Hieun-Tsang and Fahien. ( It is quite possible they were not contemproraries, so I could be mistaken). From the accounts of HieunTsang and Fahien it can be seen that there was extensive trade between present day China and India. It was around the same time that Nalanda University became the fountainhead of learning and it is widely believed that students from all over the world came here for learning. This too we learn from the accounts of HieunTsang and Fahien.
Xenophobic, I don't think so.
Another example would be the silk trade with Arabia through the old silk route via the Khyber pass. The presence of Arabian traders did not seem to create any xenophobic feelings; or so it seems. Similarly in the south, the Chola empire under Raja Raja Chola conducted extensive trade with the present day South East asian countries. He, later went on to conquer present day Malaysia, Sinagapore and Sri Lanka thus making him the first Indian king to develop a navy (This point is yet again provided for the consumption of trivia buffs.). Yet again, there seems to be no indication of xenophobia.
It was the time period after the discovery of the sea route to India by Vasco da Gama, that I believe the attitudes of Indians may have begun to change. Bear in mind that when Vasco da Gama first arrived he was treated with utmost respect. The Portugese who intially came as traders later when on to colonize parts of India. This, I suspect may have been the beginning of the wariness and skepticism towards "foreigners". The Portugese were welcomed with open arms by the local people but eventually their trust was betrayed. They not only coloonized them, but also tried to impose their religion and culture on these very people that had treated them so well. So much for "Athithi devo Bava".
Similarly the British and the French came as traders. Remember Thomas Rowe in Jahangir's court ? Better still, how about Robert Clive ? Yet again, the trust was betrayed and they went on to colonize portions of India, with the British colonizing most of it. So much so that India went on to be called the "Crown Jewel of the British Empire". Trust was broken- plain and simple.
In light of the above facts, I ask, why would the Indians not be skeptical and wary of foreigners. I still do not believe they are in anyway xenophobic. It's easy for one to say, get over it or move on. But, the wounds are still fresh in our minds. It was only 56 years ago that we won our freedom. It takes time for these wounds to heal and for the trust to be re-established.
Finally, my friend chose the example of Chinese immigrants who were discriminated against by the local Indian populace. By no means am I justifying this incident or incidents if it ever happened. China betrayed India's trust, more specifically Nehru's trust, when they invaded India in 1962. Remember the Non-aligned moment (NAM); the sloganeering, "Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai". So, is it possible that the local populace were distrustful of the motives of their Chinese brethern? Can we at least give them a fair hearing before pronouncing them guilty? Have we forgotten what the US government did to Japanese Americans after Pearl Harbor ? At least, the Indian government did not indulge in such reprehensible acts. Not that their track record is exactly impeccable but more on that later.
In conclusion, let me add that I am not justifying the skepticism and wariness of Indians towards foreigners but merely trying to understand the reasons behind such feelings. In fact, my desire would be that they become as open as they were in the times gone by. At the same time, this definitely is a rebuttal to the sweeping statement of my friend, "Indians are xenophobic".
Posted by sai at March 10, 2003 04:08 PMdear
read it
-alok
Whenever anyone says, "theoretically," they really mean, "not really."
-- Dave Parnas
tramadol
BOFH Excuse #398:
Data for intranet got routed through the extranet and landed on the internet.
prozac online A famous Lisp Hacker noticed an Undergraduate sitting in front of a Xerox
1108, trying to edit a complex Klone network via a browser. Wanting to
help, the Hacker clicked one of the nodes in the network with the mouse,
and asked "what do you see?" Very earnestly, the Undergraduate replied "I
see a cursor." The Hacker then quickly pressed the boot toggle at the back
of the keyboard, while simultaneously hitting the Undergraduate over the head
with a thick Interlisp Manual. The Undergraduate was then Enlightened.
prozac
"All Bibles are man-made."
-- Thomas Edison
fioricet for headache System going down at 5 this afternoon to install scheduler bug.
fioricet
Troglodytism does not necessarily imply a low cultural level.
buy phentermine cheap phentermineI'm sure a mathematician would claim that 0 and 1 are both very
interesting numbers. :-)
-- Larry Wall in
phentermine cheap phentermine onlineTroglodytism does not necessarily imply a low cultural level.
4904 football betting
football betting line
college football betting line
online football betting
college football betting
football betting odds
pro football betting
nfl football betting
ncaa football betting
superbowl betting
super bowl betting
sports betting football
football betting pick
florida football betting
internet football betting
football betting tip
nfl football betting line
college football betting odds
ncaa football betting line
college football betting online
online american football betting
online football betting line
pro football betting line
football betting guide
football betting uk
football betting spread
online sports betting football
sports betting football gambling
betting online pro football
football sports betting line
betting football basketball
football betting system
football betting advice
online uk football betting
football betting site
college football sports betting
betting football free
football betting game
nfl football betting odds
premiership football betting
football sport book betting
betting football sport
college football betting spread
online football betting odds
football betting sheet
betting fantasy football
betting football odds pro
football betting rule
betting football software
117 online football betting pick
ncaa college football betting line
betting football ncaa pick
betting football las line vegas
international football betting
ncaa football betting odds
betting cup football world
betting football stats
football betting strategy
arena football betting line
european football betting
betting football free line
betting football nfl sports
betting football prediction
betting football forum
betting football square
betting college football pro strategy
betting football line vegas
betting football line monday night
betting football nfl online
betting college football line odds
betting college football pick
betting college football tip
betting football monday night
betting card football
betting football las vegas
betting football online sites.com
betting football guide.com online
betting football free line nfl pick
betting football ncaa sports
betting football site web
baltimore betting football pro raven
baltimore betting football nfl raven
betting football ncaa tip
betting football free pick
betting football vegas
betting bill buffalo football nfl
betting college football las line vegas
new england patriot nfl football betting online
betting england football new nfl patriot
betting football trend
betting bill buffalo football nfl online
english football betting
betting football jet new nfl online york
betting football jet new nfl york
betting football line odds
online ncaa football betting
baltimore betting football nfl online raven
baltimore betting football online raven
685 referebce guide
Posted by: generic viagra on January 9, 2005 11:23 PMScotty: Captain, we din' can reference it!
Kirk: Analysis, Mr. Spock?
Spock: Captain, it doesn't appear in the symbol table.
Kirk: Then it's of external origin?
theSpock: Affirmative.
Kirk: Mr. Sulu, go to pass two.
Sulu: Aye aye, sir, going to pass two.
buy generic viagra cheap generic viagraDue to the closed source development model of XFree it is impossible
to support, or even speculate about, features in pre- or beta releases
of XFree.
-- Marcus Sundberg
generic viagra cheap viagra onlineScotty: Captain, we din' can reference it!
Kirk: Analysis, Mr. Spock?
Spock: Captain, it doesn't appear in the symbol table.
Kirk: Then it's of external origin?
theSpock: Affirmative.
Kirk: Mr. Sulu, go to pass two.
Sulu: Aye aye, sir, going to pass two.
7375 football betting line
college football betting line
online football betting
college football betting
football betting odds
pro football betting
nfl football betting
ncaa football betting
superbowl betting
super bowl betting
sports betting football
football betting pick
american football betting
florida football betting
internet football betting
football betting tip
nfl football betting line
college football betting odds
ncaa football betting line
college football betting online
online american football betting
online football betting line
pro football betting line
football betting guide
football betting uk
football betting spread
online sports betting football
sports betting football gambling
betting online pro football
football sports betting line
betting football basketball
sports betting odds football
football betting system
football betting advice
online uk football betting
football betting site
college football sports betting
betting football free
football betting game
nfl football betting odds
premiership football betting
football sport book betting
betting football sport
college football betting spread
online football betting odds
football betting sheet
betting fantasy football
betting football odds pro
football betting rule
betting football software
online football betting pick
ncaa college football betting line
betting football ncaa pick
betting football las line vegas
international football betting
ncaa football betting odds
betting cup football world
betting football stats
football betting strategy
arena football betting line
european football betting
betting football free line
betting football nfl sports
betting football prediction
betting football forum
betting football pool
betting football square
betting college football pro strategy
betting football line vegas
betting football line monday night
betting football nfl online
betting college football line odds
betting college football pick
betting college football tip
betting football monday night
betting card football
betting football las vegas
betting football online sites.com
betting football guide.com online
betting football free line nfl pick
betting football ncaa sports
betting football site web
baltimore betting football pro raven
baltimore betting football nfl raven
betting football ncaa tip
betting football free pick
betting football vegas
betting bill buffalo football nfl
betting college football las line vegas
new england patriot nfl football betting online
betting england football new nfl patriot
betting football trend
betting bill buffalo football nfl online
english football betting
betting football jet new nfl online york
betting football jet new nfl york
betting football line odds
online ncaa football betting
baltimore betting football nfl online raven
betting football online professional
baltimore betting football online raven
3935 Very well said franz
Posted by: hoodia gardonii on January 12, 2005 08:41 AM3614 check out the real deal...
Posted by: payday loans on January 14, 2005 05:10 AM1253 superbowl betting
super bowl betting
gambling betting odds superbowl free
superbowl betting sheets
gambling betting odds superbowl
superbowl party betting
betting lines superbowl odds
super bowl betting
gambling betting odds super bowl free
super bowl betting sheets
gambling betting odds super bowl
super bowl party betting
betting lines super bowl odds
football betting line
college football betting line
online football betting
college football betting
football betting odds
pro football betting
nfl football betting
ncaa football betting
sports betting football
football betting pick
american football betting
florida football betting
internet football betting
football betting tip
nfl football betting line
college football betting odds
ncaa football betting line
college football betting online
online american football betting
online football betting line
pro football betting line
football betting guide
football betting uk
football betting spread
online sports betting football
sports betting football gambling
betting online pro football
football sports betting line
betting football basketball
sports betting odds football
football betting system
football betting advice
online uk football betting
football betting site
college football sports betting
betting football free
football betting game
nfl football betting odds
premiership football betting
football sport book betting
betting football sport
college football betting spread
online football betting odds
football betting sheet
betting fantasy football
betting football odds pro
football betting rule
betting football software
online football betting pick
ncaa college football betting line
betting football ncaa pick
betting football las line vegas
international football betting
ncaa football betting odds
betting cup football world
betting football stats
football betting strategy
arena football betting line
european football betting
betting football free line
betting football nfl sports
betting football prediction
betting football forum
betting football pool
betting football square
betting college football pro strategy
betting football line vegas
betting football line monday night
betting football nfl online
betting college football line odds
betting college football pick
betting college football tip
betting football monday night
betting card football
betting football las vegas
betting football online sites.com
betting football guide.com online
betting football free line nfl pick
betting football ncaa sports
betting football site web
baltimore betting football pro raven
baltimore betting football nfl raven
betting football ncaa tip
betting football free pick
betting football vegas
betting bill buffalo football nfl
betting college football las line vegas
new england patriot nfl football betting online
betting england football new nfl patriot
betting football trend
betting bill buffalo football nfl online
english football betting
betting football jet new nfl online york
betting football jet new nfl york
betting football line odds
online ncaa football betting
baltimore betting football nfl online raven
betting football online professional
baltimore betting football online raven
2253 basketball betting
basketball betting line
basketball betting online
college basketball betting
college basketball betting line
ncaa basketball betting
basketball sports betting
ncaa basketball betting line
basketball betting odds
pro basketball betting
nba basketball betting
betting football basketball
ncaa basketball betting odds
college basketball betting odd
basketball basketball betting betting com
basketball betting pick
college basketball betting odds
basketball betting ncaa sports
basketball betting online pro
college basketball sports betting
online college basketball betting
basketball betting live
basketball betting tip
basketball betting information
betting ncaa basketball online
basketball betting real
basketball betting sport
basketball betting book sport
basketball betting line online
basketball betting strategy
basketball betting system
basketball betting college forum
basketball betting info ncaa tournament
basketball betting site
basketball betting guide
basketball betting professional
3218 basketball betting
basketball betting line
basketball betting online
college basketball betting
college basketball betting line
ncaa basketball betting
basketball sports betting
ncaa basketball betting line
basketball betting odds
pro basketball betting
nba basketball betting
betting football basketball
ncaa basketball betting odds
college basketball betting odd
basketball basketball betting betting com
basketball betting pick
college basketball betting odds
basketball betting ncaa sports
basketball betting online pro
college basketball sports betting
online college basketball betting
basketball betting live
basketball betting tip
basketball betting information
betting ncaa basketball online
basketball betting real
basketball betting sport
basketball betting book sport
basketball betting line online
basketball betting strategy
basketball betting system
basketball betting college forum
basketball betting info ncaa tournament
basketball betting site
basketball betting guide
basketball betting professional
1827 http://www.my-payday.com
wrinkle cream
After reading all this you should ask yourself if you donīt need to order penis enlargement products online. ICanTakeYourOrder2.
Posted by: Penis Enlargement Products on January 21, 2005 12:50 AM7554 debt consolidation
Posted by: cash advance on January 21, 2005 06:52 PMbocigalingus must be something funny.
Posted by: compatelius on January 30, 2005 02:23 PMbocigalingus must be something funny.
Posted by: compatelius on February 4, 2005 03:05 AMbocigalingus must be something funny.
Posted by: compatelius on February 4, 2005 07:37 AM[penis enlargement] [penis pills] [penis enlargement pills] [big penis] [natural penis enlargement] [penis] [enlargement penis pill]. Visit http://www.enlargement-penis-pill.info
Posted by: penis enlargement pills on February 18, 2005 03:30 PM[breast enhancement] [breast enlargement pills] [breast augmentation] [larger breast] [natural breast enlargement] [breast] [breast enlargement natural]. Visit http://www.breast-enlargement-natural.info
Posted by: natural breast enlargement on February 18, 2005 03:56 PM[sex toys] [masturbation] [male masturbation] [male sex toys] [sex toy] [fleshlight] [male sex toy]. Visit http://www.male-sex-toy.info
Posted by: sex toy on February 20, 2005 12:33 PM[sex toys] [masturbation] [male masturbation] [male sex toys] [sex toy] [fleshlight] [masturbation mutual]. Visit http://www.masturbation-mutual.info
Posted by: masturbation on February 22, 2005 01:48 PMInvestigators have found that PROPECIA increases hair growth in over 80 percent of men.
Posted by: propecia on February 23, 2005 08:31 AM[penis enlargement] [penis pills] [penis enlargement pills] [big penis] [natural penis enlargement] [penis] [enlargement penis technique]. Visit http://www.enlargement-penis-technique.info
Posted by: penis enlargement on February 24, 2005 06:34 AM[breast enhancement] [breast enlargement pills] [breast augmentation] [larger breast] [natural breast enlargement] [breast] [breast enlargement natural 4u]. Visit http://www.breast-enlargement-natural-4u.info
Posted by: breast enhancement on February 25, 2005 04:32 AM[sex toys] [masturbation] [male masturbation] [male sex toys] [sex toy] [fleshlight] [masturbation tip]. Visit http://www.masturbation-tip.info
Posted by: sex toys on February 25, 2005 04:45 AMIn Rheumatoid Arthritis, the recommended dose for CELEBREX is 100 mg to 200 mg, twice a day.
Posted by: celebrex on February 26, 2005 09:06 AMThis medication relaxes muscles and relieves pain and discomfort associated with strains, sprains, spasms or other muscle injuries.
Posted by: soma on February 26, 2005 12:29 PMGlucophage comes in tablets to take by mouth. It usually is taken two or three times a day with meals.
Posted by: glucophage on February 26, 2005 04:17 PMLipitor blocks the production of cholesterol (a type of fat) in your body.
Posted by: lipitor on February 27, 2005 08:15 AM[breast enhancement] [breast enlargement pills] [breast augmentation] [larger breast] [natural breast enlargement] [breast] [enlargement breast 4u]. Visit http://www.enlargement-breast-4u.info
Posted by: larger breast on February 27, 2005 03:13 PM[penis enlargement] [penis pills] [penis enlargement pills] [big penis] [natural penis enlargement] [penis] [enlargement free penis]. Visit http://www.enlargement-free-penis.info
Posted by: big penis on February 27, 2005 03:15 PM[sex toys] [masturbation] [male masturbation] [male sex toys] [sex toy] [fleshlight] [male sex toy]. Visit http://www.male-sex-toy.info
Posted by: sex toy on February 28, 2005 07:20 AM[travel] [travel cheap] [travel europe] [air travel] [vacation package] [ski vacation] [european vacation] [berlin hotels news]. Visit http://www.berlin-hotels-news.info
Posted by: european vacation on February 28, 2005 07:49 AMHe who is unable to live in society, or who has no need because he is sufficient for himself, must be either a beast or a god.
Posted by: homo politicus on February 28, 2005 01:11 PM